[expand]
Modern skepticism asks: what were these objects physically? If not actually serpent-created, what natural objects served as Glain Neidr?
Possibilities:
Fossilized Sea Urchins: Round, often exhibiting star patterns, found in chalk or limestone. These fossils, especially when weathered smooth, could resemble eggs, particularly to people unfamiliar with marine fossils.
Glass Beads: Roman trade brought colored glass beads to Celtic lands. Blue, green, or striped glass beads—valuable, exotic, physically impressive—could be attributed serpent origin, their actual Mediterranean manufacture unknown or ignored.
Adder Stones: Naturally occurring stones with holes, formed by water erosion or animal boring. These weren’t egg-shaped but were called “serpent stones” in folklore, attributed to snakes, used for protection and healing.
Fulgurites: Glass tubes formed when lightning strikes sand, fusing it into hollow, twisted structures. Rare, strange, formed under dramatic circumstances, these could be interpreted as serpent-created, particularly if found in locations where serpents were known to gather.
Deliberate Fakes: Unscrupulous individuals manufactured “Glain Neidr”—glass beads, carved stones, any plausible object—and sold them as authentic, taking advantage of demand and buyers’ inability to verify supernatural claims.
The physical identity mattered less than the function. A glass bead that worked as Glain Neidr—that protected its wearer, that healed wounds, that granted confidence—was, functionally, a Glain Neidr, regardless of whether serpents actually created it. The power was not intrinsic to material but emerged from belief system, ritual practice, psychological effects, and possibly placebo healing or coincidental positive outcomes attributed to the object’s presence.
[/expand]